Most cooking sites have an article like this one. They list the essential cookware pieces that every cook must have. The lists number from as few as 2 (a frying pan and a sauce pan) to as many as 10 (including every basic pan type plus other tools like knives, a cutting board, etc.).
We think the most practical number--cookware only--for most Americans' general cooking and eating habits--is 5: a skillet, a sauce pan, a Dutch oven, a roasting pan, and a baking sheet (or two).
If you have these, plus a few good knives, a cutting board, and a few other tools (strainer, spatula, whisk), you can make just about any meal imaginable. You can do everything with these 5 pieces--except baking (which is another topic).
The 5 Essentials at a Glance
Here's a table with the 5 essentials, and links to buy them on Amazon.
1. Skillet/Frying Pan
See our favorite clad stainless skillet on Amazon (Demeyere Proline)
See our favorite best-value skillet on Amazon (Cuisinart MC Pro)
See our other favorite best-value skillet on Amazon (Tramontina)
Every kitchen needs a good skillet or two. They will be your most used pans, and also your most abused pan, needing to survive high heat, hot cooking oil, and--sometimes--heavy duty scrubbing. You can scrimp on most of your other pans and you might not notice a difference in performance. But you should invest in a high quality, durable, great-performing skillet.
The right one will last a lifetime, and be a joy to use.
Most culinary experts agree that clad stainless cookware is the best all-around, daily use cookware, and we are no exception. All of our recommendations for essential pieces are good quality clad stainless cookware--but if you can only afford one piece of good clad cookware, make it your skillet.
What's A Skillet For?
Skillets are used for a ton of different cooking tasks: pan frying, stir frying, and other "dry heat" cooking methods ("dry" meaning you use small amounts of cooking oil and no other liquids--as opposed to deep frying, poaching, or braising, which are "wet heat" cooking methods). This means you'll use it for everything from frying bacon and pancakes for breakfast to making burgers, chicken, or fish for dinner. You'll also use a skillet for frying potatoes, cooking down greens, and many other side dishes--so you're likely to need more than one.
You will also use a skillet for stovetop-to-oven dishes (like frittatas), so you want a skillet that can withstand high oven and broiler temperatures.
What Makes a Good All-Around Skillet?
The best skillets have two equally important traits: durability and excellent heating properties.
Durability. Because a skillet has to withstand high temps, hot oil, and heavy use, it has to be durable. Poorly made pans won't hold up to the heat, rapid changes in temperature, and frequent use that a skillet is going to get in most kitchens. (How will they not hold up? They'll warp, the handles will fall off, the lids will break, and they'll scratch, pit, and rust.)
On the other hand, you don't want a skillet that's so heavy it's hard to use. While many people love cast iron, we don't for this exact reason: anything larger than 10 inches in diameter is going to be hard to handle. (Cast iron also has mediocre heating properties: it takes forever to heat through--although once hot, it holds onto heat like a champion, making it excellent for certain kitchen tasks like deep frying and searing steaks. So while we don't recommend cast iron for your daily use pan, we do think it's a great supplementary skillet to have. It gets bonus points for being inexpensive, too.)
Stainless handles and lids (as opposed to plastic handles and glass lids) are also best for durability and longevity. All of the clad stainless pans we recommend have stainless handles and lids. (You should avoid cookware with glass lids, which are heavy and have a tendency to shatter under rapid temperature changes.)
Heating Properties. Good heating properties are equally important. Because what good is a pan that will last forever, but doesn't heat well?
What makes for good heating properties? A skillet should heat rapidly and evenly. Heat should spread throughout the skillet, and all the way up the sides. (For this reason, we don't recommend a bottom-clad skillet, although bottom-cladding can work fine for other pots, like stock pots and sauce pans.)
Not all clad stainless is created equally. Understanding why is a topic worthy of a separate post, but suffice to say that inexpensive clad cookware can have thin layers of aluminum, causing it to heat unevenly. If you're interested in learning more, check out our article The Best Cookware Set for Every Budget.
Shape. Most people prefer a skillet with a good amount of flat cooking surface. You might be surprised to learn that not all skillets do. Some are wok-shaped, with very sloped sides and a smaller flat bottom, like this Tramontina skillet:
Others have straighter sides, making for more cooking surface, like this Demeyere Industry 5 skillet (which also happens to be our favorite pick):
The difference doesn't look huge, but the bottom diameter of the Tramontina skillet is more than an inch smaller. When cooking large pieces of meat like hamburgers or chicken breasts, you will appreciate a larger flat cooking area. (Although, other than the smaller flat bottom, the Tramontina is a really nice skillet at a much lower price.)
The Cuisinart MC Pro skillet is an inexpensive option with a nice shape:
Nice Features: You can also look for nice extras like a helper handle (most 12-inch skillets have one), a curved lip for mess-free pouring, and an included lid--skillets typically do not come with lids, but sometimes you can find them (such as this All-Clad skillet with lid included).
The skillet gets the hardest use of any pan in your kitchen, so this is where you should invest your kitchen dollar. You can go cheap on other cookware and not regret it, but not so with a skillet. You want to get the best one you can afford.
What Size Skillet Should I Get?
Realistically, a well-stocked kitchen should have a few skillets of different sizes, or a skillet and a sauté pan of a few different sizes. For your daily use, go-to pan, we recommend a 12-inch skillet.
Anything smaller is going to be a pain to use, requiring you to cook in batches because you won't be able to fit everything in the pan at the same time (and this is often true even if you're only cooking for two).
For smaller meals and side dishes, it's nice to have a smaller skillet around, too. For this we recommend a 10-inch skillet (or a 3-4 quart sauté pan, if you'd prefer).
If you frequently make crepes, omelets, or cook for just yourself, you may find an 8-inch skillet useful. But in general, an 8-inch skillet is awfully small, and not terribly useful for most cooks.
With the exception of this Tramontina 12 Piece set (you'll find the best price at Wal-Mart), few cookware sets come with a 12-inch skillet; most come with a 10-inch and an 8-inch skillet. If you're interested in a smaller set that has a 10-inch skillet, go ahead and get it--it's usually the most economical way to buy cookware--then supplement with the bigger skillet. This approach works well for many people, if you'll use all the pieces in the set you buy.
Of course, you can buy the 12-piece set from Tramontina, too, but a set this large is a gamble, as you may not need all of those pieces.
NOTE: For more information about Tramontina cookware, see our Tramontina tri-ply cookware review.
If you decide to buy a set, pay careful attention to the size of the pieces. They can vary quite a bit among different retailers.
How Much Should I Spend on a Skillet?
Having said you should invest in a skillet, you don't need to break the bank if it's not in your budget. Yes, our favorites are spendy: both Demeyere and All-Clad will set you back more than a hundred dollars. These skillets are built like tanks and will last forever, and you will appreciate their heft and quality every time you use them.
When you consider that these are products that will last a lifetime, the cost-per-year-of-use is small, so if you can afford a top notch brand, we highly recommend buying one. (Especially the Demeyere, which has about 75% more aluminum than the All-Clad, making for much superior heating properties.)
However, there are a few less expensive brands that are almost as good. These are Cuisinart MultiClad Pro and Tramontina tri-ply. If you go with one of these brands, a 12-inch skillet will set you back about $60.
What About Nonstick Skillets?
Nonstick skillets aren't a "top 5" pan because they have a lot of drawbacks, but they're a nice extra skillet to have.
See below for our nonstick recommendations.
Buy a Demeyere skillet on amazon now:
BUY A Cuisinart MC-Pro skillet ON AMAZON NOW:
2. Sauce Pan
What's A Sauce Pan For?
A sauce pan is your go-to kitchen essential for wet cooking methods. You do everything with it you can't do with a skillet: soups, making pasta, making hot cereals, boiling veggies (steaming too if you have an insert), sauces, custards and puddings, gravies, reductions, and so. much. more.
What Makes Good All-Around Sauce Pan?
Heating Properties and Durability: As with all cookware, you want a durable sauce pan with good heating properties.
Having said that, a sauce pan doesn't need to be quite as durable as a skillet because cooking with liquids isn't as hard on cookware as cooking with oil.
Also, the heating properties aren't quite as important as for a skillet because liquids spread heat through natural convection. Thus, even heating happens naturally and the amount of aluminum and/or copper in a pan isn't as crucial.
However, you do want a sauce pan with some heft just so it lasts, resists warping, and will work well even if you're using it for viscous foods (e.g., oatmeal, stew) or dry heat cooking. Even if you don't need the superior heating properties, you will appreciate the heft and excellent construction of a well made sauce pan.
Design: Ideally, a sauce pan should have straight sides: curved sides might be pretty, but they're harder to scrape food out of, clean, and store (no stacking!). It should have a tight-fitting stainless lid, a handle that feels comfortable to grip and good for stabilizing and maneuvering. If it's larger than 3 quarts, a helper handle is a nice extra feature.
Sauce pans can have a wide, shallow shape or a tall, deep shape (you can easily see this difference in our two favorite picks shown above). Neither design is inherently better than the other, so go with your personal preference.
Pouring: Some sauce pans have grooved lips, which is nice for pouring, but not essential. Our favorite, the All-Clad tri-ply, doesn't have a pouring lip but still pours nicely. The cheaper Cuisinart MC Pro sauce pan does have a pouring lip--but it isn't quite as pretty or as heavy as the All-Clad.
The best sauce pans are clad stainless: these will provide good heating properties and decades of durable service. There is no reason to ever, ever buy a nonstick sauce pan.
What's the Best Size Sauce Pan to Get?
For an all-around sauce pan, we recommend at least a 3 quart size. This is the minimum size for boiling pasta easily. A 1- or 2-quart is good mostly for heating cans of soup, making sauces, and other small jobs. You may even want a 4- or 5-quart, especially if it's going to do double duty as a small stock pot.
Once again, if you're buying a set, pay attention to the sauce pan size(s). Just like skillets, sauce pans are going to be small. We recommend not buying a set without a 3-quart sauce pan. (It's okay if there are smaller sauce pans included, but you really need at least a 3-quart to be considered an all-around, go-to sauce pan.)
About the All-Clad D3 Sauce Pan: The All-Clad sauce pan is a sturdy workhorse that will last for decades. It has a wide, not-too-deep shape that makes it great to cook with. This model, the tri-ply (D3), has completely straight sides, lacking a lip for pouring. Other All-Clad lines do have a lip (such as the Copper Core and the D5), but these cost quite a bit more without having significantly better heating properties. For this reason, we prefer the D3 line.
The D3 also has the traditional All-Clad grooved, U-shaped handle. This handle gets a lot of bad press, but we really like it. The grooved shape makes it easy to stabilize even if wet--if a sauce pan full of hot liquid has ever slipped out of your grip, you'll appreciate how nearly impossible it is for that to happen with this handle design.
About the Cuisinart MultiClad Pro sauce pan: Although a little lighter weight than the All-Clad D3 and not as pretty, this pan comes in a close second place. It's design it a bit deeper and narrower than we like, but it's well made and has the grooved lip that the D3 lacks. The finish isn't quite as polished and the stainless may not be quite as high quality as All-Clad, but that is reflected in the (much) lower price.
For a fraction of the cost of All-Clad, this is a really great sauce pan.
BUY All-Clad sauce D3 pan ON AMAZON NOW:
BUY CUISINART MC-PRO SAUCE PAN ON AMAZON NOW:
3. Dutch Oven
See our favorite all-around Dutch oven on Amazon (le Creuset)
If you buy a set of clad stainless cookware, it's likely that you'll get a Dutch oven in the mix. Even so, you won't regret investing in an enameled cast iron Dutch oven. You'll love it.
What's A Dutch oven For?
A Dutch oven is primarily for braising--wet heat in the oven--but it's a great all-around pan you can also use as a skillet, stock pot, even a large sauce pan. This makes it ideal for soups, stews, and braises, which start out with searing mirepoix and meat, then adding liquid and simmering.
Because of its all-around versatility and one-pot dinner functionality, you'll find yourself reaching for your Dutch oven frequently. It's as versatile as a deep sauté pan, but it's bigger, with two short handles that make it ideal for oven braises.
What Makes Good All-Around Dutch oven?
Good heating properties are essential, but in the case of a Dutch oven, what makes for good heating is a little bit different.
First of all, the cast iron construction works a little differently than clad stainless. The cast iron doesn't heat all that quickly or all that evenly (like the aluminum in the clad stainless cookware), but once heated through, it hangs onto heat really, really well. This is what makes it so great for oven braising and even bread baking. It's also an excellent vessel for deep frying for the same reasons.
Another reason you want cast iron for Dutch ovens is the heavy lid. The ample weight gives the lid a tighter fit than you'll get from lighter stainless lids. This means enameled cast iron pots will lose less liquid, making them the best vessel for braising.
As far as durability, cast iron construction makes it a given. Lower priced enameled cast iron may require a bit more careful handling, as the enamel will be more prone to chipping. But in general, these pots are tough as nails: they'll take a lot of use and abuse and last for decades.
If you bought a set of clad stainless and got a Dutch oven with it, you don't need to go out and buy a cast iron one. The clad stainless Dutch oven will be fine for many things--stocks, stews, soups. But for oven braising and deep frying, it's hard to beat enameled cast iron.
What about non-enameled cast iron Dutch ovens? Yes, they're considerably less expensive, and they'll last forever. The only problem with them is that certain foods--in particular, acidic foods--will react with cast iron, and can impart an off taste. You don't want to use cast iron for any dishes with tomatoes, which rules out quite a few recipes.
Enameled cast iron is much more versatile.
le Creuset vs. less expensive brands. You can get a nice enameled cast iron pot for a tenth of the price of le Creuset, so why spend the money on le Creuset? Mostly durability, but there are a few other considerations such as weight, balance, handle design, and shape. This video from America's Test Kitchen explains the differences really well:
What Size Dutch Oven Should I Get?
This is dependent on how you cook, but a good standard size is 5- or 6-quarts. This is about the size you need for an average sized pot roast or chicken.
If you routinely cook large batches, you can go larger, but we don't recommend going below 4 quarts unless you want it primarily for side dishes.
BUY A le creuset dutch oven ON AMAZON NOW:
BUY A LODGE DUTCH OVEN ON AMAZON NOW:
4. Roasting Pan (or Large Baking Pan)
See our favorite all-around roasting pan on Amazon (Cuisinart Chef's Classic)
See a good nonstick roasting pan on Amazon (Circulon)
What's A Roasting Pan For?
This probably doesn't need an explanation, but a roasting pan is for roasting meats in the oven.
Roasting is different than braising in that the meat is exposed to the hot oven air in order to produce a crispy, browned exterior. You can use an uncovered Dutch oven for this, but the high sides discourage browning. You can use a skillet or sauté pan, too, but these often aren't big enough, or wrongly shaped, for the cuts of meat you use a roaster for.
Because it's made for oven use, a roasting pan has an entirely different set of criteria for what makes it "good" than other cookware on our list.
Why Is a Roasting Pan "Essential"?
A roasting pan is only essential if you roast meat. If you're a vegetarian, a roasting pan is definitely not a kitchen essential.
In fact, a designated roasting pan may not be essential even if you do eat meat. If you like to bake, you probably have one or two vessels that you could use for roasting. A 9x13 cake pan works, as does any shallow glass or ceramic pans.
However, you may want a pan just for meat--particularly if it comes with a roasting rack, which allows air to circulate all around the cut of meat and produce a fully browned exterior. This is hard to achieve in a cake pan.
What Makes Good All-Around Roasting Pan?
With a roasting pan, heating properties are less important than for any other piece of cookware. Because oven heat hits the food from all sides and not just from a burner, the pan is not transferring heat into the food. You can use pretty much any type of pan for roasting, whether glass, ceramic, stainless, or nonstick, and it will produce fine results.
You can even buy disposable aluminum roasting pans that work just fine. (Just be sure to put them on a baking sheet because they're not sturdy enough to hold their shape on their own.)
So what makes a good roasting pan, then? Here are a few thoughts:
- Good, easy-to-grip handles (important because those pans are hot and heavy!)
- Large enough for what you want to use it for
- Comes with a roasting rack (many do not).
You don't need clad stainless, or really, any high end pan at all. The pans we recommend are some of the cheapest roasters on Amazon.
If you want a high-end roaster, by all means spend the money. (You'll never regret getting the good stuff.) But if you're looking for ways to cut corners and still have an excellent set of cookware, the roaster should be the first item to go!
About the Chef's Classic roasting pan: Chef's Classis is a less expensive Cuisinart line than the Multi-Clad Pro. This roasting pan is clad stainless, but the stainless isn't the best quality (the primary reason to get an All-Clad roaster). But at this price, you can take the chance because you can replace about 4-5 times over before getting close to the A/C price.
The pan claims to be induction compatible (only important if you want to use the pan on the stovetop, say for making gravy), but it may not be.
Otherwise, this pan is a good shape, it comes with a stainless rack, and it has decent handles for maneuverability. What else do you need?
About the Circulon nonstick roasting pan: Yes, a nonstick roasting pan! Why not? Well, it won't last as long as clad stainless, but hey, that's a small price to pay for easy cleaning.
Roasting pans can get stained pretty fast, so easy cleaning is really attractive feature. This pan has a really nice rack with handles for easy lifting from the pan (ideal for when you want that meat to rest while you make a gravy). The handles are still going to get spattered and stained, but overall, much easier to care for.
What Size Roasting Pan Should You Get?
In general, you want a pan that's approximately 16 inches by 13 inches, not including handles. This is large enough for a big turkey and just about anything else.
If you have a small oven, you should get one with handles that don't stick out too much, or that fold down.
A 13x9 cake (or lasagna) pan will also work for most meats. You can even find some "lasagna" pans that come with a roasting rack, like this one. The advantage is that these are more versatile than a designated roasting pan; the disadvantage is that they're smaller. Or maybe that's the advantage, depending on what you want.
BUY Cuisinart Chef'S Classic Roasting pan ON AMAZON NOW:
BUY CIRCULON NONSTICK ROASTING PAN ON AMAZON NOW:
5. Baking Sheets/Sheet Pans
Baking sheets, also called sheet pans, are a kitchen essential. No matter what your kitchen style, no matter what your diet, you will get a ton of use out of them. If you use an oven, you will use sheet pans. In fact, you will use them so frequently that you should have at least a couple on hand.
What Are Sheet Pans For?
Baking sheets have become hugely popular in recent years for making sheet pan suppers, easy one-pan meals where you toss the meat and veggies straight in the oven for a quick roast. But we've been using them for years for myriad kitchen tasks:
- baking cookies
- baking sheet cakes and bars
- homemade pizza
- roasting bacon (best done with a rack)
- roasting veggies
- catching drips from pies and casseroles
- under pie plates for easy lifting out of the oven without ruining the crust
- under disposable pans (also for easy handling)
- dehydrating fruits and veggies
- sheet pan dinners
- heating leftovers and takeout food
- thawing frozen foods
- and much more!
Quarter sheet pans--9x13 inches or so--make great, inexpensive trays to corral clutter, too. Just don't use them for baking--ever!--or they will lose their shine.
What Makes Good All-Around Sheet Pan?
You should think of sheet pans as being inexpensive and replaceable. Because no matter how much you spend, you're going to want to replace them every 3-5 years.
The only real requirement we think is essential is that they be stainless steel. Stainless is the safest and most durable material. You don't want aluminum because it can react with food (and is a potential health hazard). You don't want nonstick because it will wear out too quickly. You don't want glass because you're going to pay too much for it (unless you're buying it for other bakeware purposes as well).
Sheet pans should be a standard size, as well. Most large home-use sheet pans are actually half sheet pans, and are approximately 13x18 inches; quarter sheet pans, also useful for a ton of things (though not large enough for sheet pan dinners), are 13x9 inches.
If you buy racks separately, it's important that your baking sheets be a standard size. It's also easier for storage (as opposed to having a bunch in different sizes).
How Much Should You Spend on a Sheet Pan?
Not a lot. Stainless pans are going to be a little more expensive than aluminum, so you should spend enough to get stainless. Other than that, you don't need any other features. Sheet pans are something you'll get a few years of use out of, then you'll want to replace them. There's no need to get anything fancy.
You may want to get one with a rack included--the option linked to here is the cheapest we've seen on Amazon--or you may want to buy a rack separately. Both are good options.
You may not think you'll use a rack, but that's probably because you've never made bacon in the oven. A rack essentially turns your baking sheet into a shallow roasting pan, so your meat browns all the way around and won't get soggy. It's essential for fatty meats (like bacon) so they don't turn soggy in their own juices.
Having said all of that, you should be able to find half sheet pans (standard size for home use) and quarter sheet pans for under $10 apiece.
Amazon has a huge array of sheet pans in all shapes, sizes, and materials. Check out the Amazon selection here.
BUY set of 2 sheet pans (different sizes) ON AMAZON NOW:
BUY SET OF 2 SHEET PANS WITH RACK ON AMAZON NOW:
Optional, But Good, Pieces to Have (Depending on Your Cooking Style)
These are in no particular order, because what makes a piece good for you (maybe even essential) is based on your personal cooking style and preferences.
See our favorite all-around nonstick skillet on Amazon (All-Clad HA1)
See our other favorite nonstick skillet on Amazon (Anolon Nouvelle Copper)
A lot of people consider a nonstick skillet an essential piece. In fact, a lot of people buy entire sets of nonstick cookware. We, however, abhor nonstick cookware for most tasks, and consider it a necessary compromise for certain tasks.
Why do we dislike nonstick cookware for daily use? For one, it's incredibly fragile, with even the most durable nonstick coating lasting only a few years under most conditions. You can't use metal utensils, put it in a dishwasher, or use anything above medium heat (at least for PTFE; ceramic can withstand high heat, but it seems to shorten the nonstick coating's life span even more).
In other words, you really have to baby it in order to get the most life out of it--and even then, you're just not going to get anything near what you'd get out of a clad stainless pan.
So while we much prefer clad stainless for most frying tasks (with cast iron being a distant second), a nonstick skillet might be a useful addition to your kitchen if you'll use it for the tasks it does best.
What's A Nonstick Skillet For?
Nonstick skillets excel at sticky, delicate foods that do best with gentle heat and don't need a lot of browning for delicious results: eggs and fish are the two foods that come to mind.
You may also use a nonstick skillet to make sticky things like caramel and candied nuts. For sticky foods like this, nonstick provides easy cleanup that's hard to beat. (If you've ever tried to clean burnt-on sugar from a stainless skillet, you'll understand the appeal of nonstick here.)
Are There Other (Non-Toxic) Options Instead of Nonstick?
Yes and no, depending on how much non-nonstick you're willing to put up with. The two options that come closest are cast iron and carbon steel.
Cast iron: Cast iron has been around for thousands of years and is the "original" nonstick cookware. It requires seasoning but once properly seasoned, it provides a slick surface that comes close to nonstick. You still have to use cooking oil to get desired results, and it's never going to equal PTFE for slipperiness. But many people love it, and it's a viable alternative to nonstick if you're willing to keep the pan seasoned and don't mind the bulk.
Cast iron doesn't have the greatest heating properties, being slow to heat and having lots of hot and cold spots. Once heated, though, cast iron hangs onto heat like a champion (this is due mostly to its mass--it's thick and heavy), so it's great not only for a pseudo-nonstick pan, but also for high heat searing (think putting a thick, crusty sear on a steak, for example).
Cast iron is inexpensive, and many consider it an essential piece of cookware. Why don't we? Well, it's heavy and hard to handle, and like we said, the heating properties don't match those of clad stainless. But if you want a decent all-around skillet that doubles as almost nonstick, cast iron is a good choice.
In the last couple of years, some high-end cast iron has entered the market. It's made the "old school" way, which actually does result in slightly better heating properties. But really, it's not worth the money (some of these pans cost 10 times what you'd pay for a Lodge skillet!). Unless you have a lot of disposable income, you'd be better off investing in a high-end clad stainless skillet like the Demeyere Proline, and using your cheap-but-always-reliable cast iron for what it's best at: searing steaks, frying chicken, and other tasks that do best in pans that hold on to heat really well.
Instead, we recommend buying an inexpensive cast iron skillet--pre-seasoned ones are a good option if you don't want to go through the seasoning process (although it's pretty simple).
We also recommend that, unless you're a big, strong guy, you shouldn't go above a 10-inch diameter. Cast iron is heavy, and anything bigger than 10-inches is going to be hard to use.
Carbon steel: Carbon steel is cast iron's lighter weight cousin. It requires similar seasoning to create a slick surface, as well as similar care and use (using cooking oil and washing with water only, for example). It's also inexpensive, like cast iron, and many people are huge fans of carbon steel skillets. Here is a new, non-seasoned carbon steel skillet:
Carbon steel's drawbacks are that with its lighter mass and thinner walls, it lacks cast iron's ability to hang onto heat well--meaning that as far as heating properties, it has few redeeming qualities.
If you're averse to nonstick cookware because of its possible health hazards and averse to cast iron for its considerable weight and bulkiness, carbon steel is a viable alternative. But it's not our favorite option.
Carbon steel is lighter weight than cast iron, but it's still heavy. Don't let that thin-looking wall fool you; this is dense stuff, and can be almost as bulky as cast iron. So as with cast iron, we recommend not going much bigger than 10- or 11-inches in diameter.
What Makes Good All-Around Nonstick Skillet?
Heating Properties: Like all cookware, heating properties are important. If you buy a cast (or forged) aluminum nonstick skillet, excellent heating properties are built in. Both of our picks, the All-Clad cast aluminum and the Anolon Copper Nouvelle, both provide thick aluminum walls that give great performance.
Pan Shape: Shape is another important consideration. Ideally a skillet should have short, steep sides and a lot of flat cooking surface--yet not so steep that it's hard to get a turner in there to flip a burger or chicken breast. But in general, the more flat cooking surface, the better.
This is where our two favorite picks differ considerable. The All-Clad HA1 skillet has a really nice shape with a lot of usable flat surface, yet nicely sloped sides that make it easy to get inside of with a turner:
The Anolon Copper Nouvelle skillet, although it has better heating properties with an astonishing (for the price) amount of copper in the base, is a little too wok-like, with long sides and a small flat cooking surface, for our liking, as you can see here:
If it were shaped like the All-Clad pan, it would be our number one choice, no contest. But as it is, it's great for some tasks (like stir frying), but not so much for pan frying fish.
But hey, if you're using it primarily for eggs, this may not be a problem.
Size: If you're using the nonstick skillet for eggs, a 10-inch skillet is probably big enough. If you're going to use it for other jobs, you may want a 12-inch. However, going up to 12-inches is going to cost considerably more, so be sure you need that much room before you buy it.
Extras: As with your clad stainless skillet, you may want a grooved lip for easy pouring (the Anolon Copper Nouvelle has a grooved lip, the All-Clad HA1 does not), a great handle (stainless is our favorite), and a lid (some skillets come with lids, but most do not). If you buy cheap, you may get a plastic or silicone handle, which we do not recommend. They wear out easily and don't withstand any oven use at all. You might also prefer a nonstick skillet with a rivetless cooking surface, like this one from Tramontina that we like (although it's a little expensive, particularly with that silicone handle).
How Much Should You Spend on a Nonstick Skillet?
The short answer is, "not a lot." Because of the short life span of nonstick coatings, you should spend a fraction of what you would spend on a clad stainless skillet (which will last for a lifetime an then some).
What does this mean in practice? Our advice is to not spend more than $50 dollars on a 10-inch nonstick skillet. If you want a 12-inch, you may have to go above that number, but you should try to keep it as low as possible.
The good news is that you can get really nice performance even under $50. The secret is to buy cast aluminum rather than clad stainless nonstick (too expensive) or stamped aluminum (usually too thin to provide even heating). Cast (or forged) aluminum provides excellent heating properties; as good as clad stainless, if not better (because there's more aluminum than in most clad stainless pans). And with the nonstick cooking surface, the aluminum is completely safe to use (at least until the nonstick coating scratches or wears off).
What about ceramic nonstick? Just as with traditional PTFE (i.e., Teflon, buy cheap. Ceramic is great while it lasts, but by most accounts (and personal experience), it has an even shorter life span than PTFE. PTFE is safe when used properly, but we recommend ceramic nonstick for people who have household members who may not use it correctly (too high heat, metal utensils, the dishwasher, etc.). Green Pan and Healthy Legend are both good brands; they aren't the prettiest cookware, and the glass lids aren't ideal, but they're reputable brands that ensure safe ceramic cookware.
BUY All-Clad HA1 nonstick SKILLET ON AMAZON NOW:
BUY Anolon Nouvelle Copper NONSTICK SKILLET ON AMAZON NOW:
Deep Sauté Pan
See our favorite all-around deep sauté pan on Amazon (All-Clad D3)
While not as popular as some other pan types, the deep sauté pan is a fabulous multi-duty piece of cookware. In fact, it's one of the most versatile pans to have in your kitchen.
What Is A Deep Sauté Pan Used For?
You can use a deep sauté pan for many different cooking tasks: frying, deep frying, poaching, sauces, soups, stews, making stock, braising, making pasta, rice, and beans, plus numerous other cooking tasks.
Thus, in a pinch, you can do pretty much anything in it: it's shallow enough to work as a frying pan, yet deep enough to use for braises, soups, stews, and stocks. You can use it on the stovetop and in the oven.
Think of it as an oversized sauté pan or sauce pan, or a smallish Dutch oven. And it not only does all of these tasks; it's good at them.
Yes; you can do most of these things with a Dutch oven, also, but here's the difference: the deep sauté pan is a little shallower than the Dutch oven, so it's easier to use for frying, deep frying, and sautéing. Yet it's as perfect as a Dutch oven or small stock pot for soups and stews.
The only thing it's not ideal for is sauce-making; if you do a lot of that, then a Chef's pan or large sauciér is a better option--the sloped sides are easier for a whisk to reach.
What Makes A Good Deep Sauté Pan?
Heating Properties. Like any other piece of cookware, you want it to have decent heating properties. And because it's an all-purpose pan which you will use for dry cooking and wet cooking methods, it should preferably be fully clad.
Durability: Because you'll be using this pan for so many different tasks, durability is also a must. Durability is built in to a clad stainless pan like the All-Clad D3 deep sauté pan. Stay away from nonstick and poorly made options. They won't perform well, and they won't last.
Shape/Size: You want a deep sauté pan to be, well, deep. There are a lot of options on the market that really aren't very deep. In fact, the All-Clad pan is one of the few we've found with nice deep sides. (If/when we find a cheaper alternative, we'll be sure to add a link to it.)
The All-Clad deep sauté pan is 6 quarts, and that's about as small as you should go. Anything smaller than that probably isn't going to be as deep as you want a deep sauté pan to be.
Design: A grooved lip is nice for pouring--and you will be pouring from this pan occasionally. A lid is also a must, preferably stainless. If it has a helper handle, that's a huge plus as well, because this pan can get heavy when it's full--and if it's full of hot oil, a helper handle is a necessity for safety's sake.
How Much Should You Spend on a Deep Sauté Pan?
Seeing as how the only deep sauté pan we really like is an All-Clad pan, it's not cheap, at about $185. Unfortunately, this is the only pan we've found with these dimensions, and they're perfect for so many things; wide enough to use as a frying pan but deep enough to use as an oversized sauce pan (perfect for long pasta if you don't have a pasta pot!).
If that's over your budget, you can find other all-purpose pans, like a chef's pan or large saucier, which provide similar versatility, in a cheaper line. You may even like them better than a deep sauté pan: a lot of people do. We prefer the more stable base and straight sides of this pan, but we may be in the minority, as chef's pans/large sauciers are very popular.
BUY A deep sauté pan ON AMAZON NOW:
See our favorite all-around sauté pan on Amazon (All-Clad D3)
See our favorite best-value sauté pan on Amazon (Cuisinart MC Pro)
A sauté pan isn't a kitchen essential because you can do everything a sauté pan can do with a skillet. Nevertheless, they're a nice piece to have for a number of reasons: the straight sides result in less spattering than a skillet, they have more flat cooking surface than comparably sized skillets, and they come with a lid for wet cooking methods--and, for an added bonus, this lid will often fit your skillet, too.
Some cooks prefer a sauté pan to a skillet, and that's perfectly fine. But a lot of cooks prefer to use a skillet when they can and a sauté pan when they have to because sauté pans are bulkier and a little trickier to maneuver. For these reasons, we consider a sauté pan a nice extra, but not a kitchen essential.
And if you do want a sauté pan, consider the deep sauté pan (see above). It's a fabulously versatile pan.
What's A Sauté Pan For?
A sauté pan is essentially a skillet with straight, rather than sloped, sides. It's almost always sold with a cover, while a skillet is rarely sold with one. These two things give you a clue about the difference between these two pans: a sauté pan is designed primarily for wet cooking methods (poaching, braising, etc.), while a skillet is used primarily for frying.
Another clue is how they're measured. Skillets are measured by diameter--8-inch, 10-inch, 12-inch, from top rim to top rim. Sauté pans are measured by volume: 3 quart, 4 quart, 6 quart. So this is another clue that they're designed for liquid cooking.
And it's true: sauté pans, with their straight sides and lids, are perfect for cooking down big batches of greens, for poaching chicken breasts, and even for deep frying--whereas the sloped sides of a skillet, as well as its lack of a lid, make it less than ideal for any of these jobs.
In fact, if you had to pick one or the other, the sauté pan is the right choice, because it's a more versatile pan. But its straight sides make it less than ideal for many pan frying tasks: it's harder to get a turner in there to flip foods. Their squarish shape also gives them a bulkier, less maneuverable feel than skillets.
Which is why many people have both: skillets for pan frying, sauté pans for poaching, braising, and, in a pinch, frying, too.
For more details about the differences between these pans, see our article Should I Buy a Skillet, a Sauté Pan, or Both?
What Makes Good All-Around Sauté Pan?
Like every pan, it's a combination of great heating properties, durability, and easy-to-use design.
Assuming we stick to our two favorite options, the heating properties and durability are both givens; the All-Clad pan is going to heat a little more evenly, but they are both very good quality pans, with stainless cooking surfaces, tight-fitting lids, helper handles (they can get heavy when full!), and a nice balance that makes the pan feel good in your hand.
These are all important features of a sauté pan. Additionally, you may want a pan with a grooved rim for easy pouring.
The most important thing is that the pan is not too big so that it's bulky and hard to work with. This is a bigger problem with sauté pans than skillets because they're squarer in shape, so they can feel a lot harder to maneuver.
To avoid this, stay on the small side: no bigger than 3- or 4-quarts. (Or, if you go for the deep sauté pan, 6-quart.) This is roughly the equivalent of a 10-inch diameter skillet, but with considerably more flat surface area. This size also ensures even heating on most burners--if you go much over the burner size, too much of the cooking surface extends beyond the burner, making for less even heating.
How Much Should You Spend on a Sauté Pan?
Since a sauté pan is an extra, you may not want to spend a lot on it. However, this is a pan you're going to use a lot; almost as much as your skillet, and maybe more if you find you prefer the sauté pan. And if you want it to double as a skillet occasionally, you're going to want it to be durable and have excellent heating properties.
A sauté pan, much like a skillet, is an investment. A good one will last decades.
The Cuisinart MC Pro is a really nice pan, but the All-Clad is going to win on performance. Not by a lot, but by enough that it might make a difference to you. Although for about half the price, you may be willing to live with the less-than-perfect MC Pro. Either way you decide to go, it's a great investment, and both come with a lifetime warranty.
Should you want to go even cheaper, you can find sauté pans with bottom cladding only. Depending on how you plan on using the pan, this might be just fine. If you're going to use it primarily for wet heat cooking, a bottom-clad sauté pan works great. However, if you're ever going to use it as a skillet, too, you want fully clad sides so you have good heat transfer throughout the entire pan.
BUY the All-Clad sauté pan ON AMAZON NOW:
BUY the Cuisinart Mc Pro sauté pan ON AMAZON NOW:
The best woks are carbon steel, which means they are inexpensive. They're a good addition to your cookware collection if you like Asian food and have the storage space for this large, bulky piece of cookware--because if you buy one, you should get a large one: the most common size for home use is 14-inch, measured across the top diameter.
What's A Wok For?
Woks are used for stir frying. Stir frying is an Asian cooking technique in which the food--including veggies and meat--is cut into bite-sized pieces before cooking. Because the pieces are small, the food cooks rapidly and almost always at the highest heat possible. You use the sloped sides to manipulate which food is cooking: once the meat is cooked, for example, you can push it up the sides while you give the veggies a quick sizzle in the bottom, where it's hottest. Finish with a sauce, which bubbles and thickens quickly.
Wok cooking is kind of the original one pan meal. The prepping takes the longest, but the cooking itself usually takes under 10 minutes.
Problems with Woks
It can be difficult getting really good wok performance at home. Restaurants are equipped with special, high-powered wok burners, often concave, or large enough so the wok sits well inside the burner, to create more surface contact on the bottom.
This is hard to do at home. The small bottom on the wok creates little contact with the heat source, which is problematic. A gas stove gives the best performance because the flames spread heat, but even so, most home gas ranges simply aren't powerful enough to get a wok hot enough for optimal wok cooking.
Also, restaurant woks typically convex bottoms, while home woks should have flat bottoms to create the most contact with the heat source while retaining the wok shape.
This doesn't mean woks aren't viable for home use. They are--but you may not get results like the takeout from your local Chinese restaurant.
Can you get similar results from a large skillet or sauté pan? Yes, you can, for the most part. Which is why a wok is an optional piece of cookware. But if you like Asian stir frying, home wokking can be a lot of fun.
Ways to Improve Home Wok Performance
- As we already said, buy a flat-bottomed wok if you're going to use it on your conventional stove. A convex bottom will have almost no contact with the heat source.
- Gas hobs are better than electric hobs.
- Buy a special wok burner (use with caution!):
What Makes a Good Wok?
You can find all sorts of "Americanized" woks, some with nonstick coating, or made out of tri-ply clad stainless, with covers, or so flat-bottomed that they're not much more than a large chef's pan.
But if you want an "authentic" wok, your best bet is an inexpensive carbon steel wok. They hold heat (as a wok should), they provide good performance, and they're as close to "authentic" as you're going to find.
Carbon steel is also going to be durable, and should last a lifetime.
Like all carbon steel cookware, they need to be seasoned properly. Once seasoned, though, they are a breeze to use: the almost nonstick surface is easy to cook with and really easy to keep clean, requiring a quick wipeout and a quick oiling to prevent rusting.
As far as size, a 14 inch is the best size to go with. You want a large, deep wok so you can stir fry with vigor and not have to worry about food flying out of the pan. Also, this large size really sets it apart from other skillets and sauté pans, which simply aren't going to be this large.
And remember, get a flat-bottomed wok for best results on a home burner.
BUY A wok ON AMAZON NOW:
See our favorite chef's pan on Amazon (All-Clad tri-ply)
If you don't want to commit to a wok but want a larger, more general purpose pan that can function like a wok, a chef's pan is a good way to go.
What's A Chef's Pan For?
Chef's pans are large and versatile, good for many cooking tasks including pan frying, deep frying, stir frying, braising, poaching, and more. In fact, they get their name for being such a good all-around pan--one that a chef can put to many good uses.
A similar pan is called a sauciér pan, but it's usually smaller, and therefore not as versatile. (Click here to see one on Amazon.) Sauciér pans are so called because they're used primarily for making sauces: their rounded sides leave no spots for a whisk to miss.
We prefer the chef's pan: because it's larger, it's more versatile, but otherwise, it is essentially the same pan as a sauciér. So if you're cooking for just one or two, or like to make a lot of sauces in small amounts, go for the sauciér instead of the chef's pan.
What Makes Good All-Around Chef's Pan?
Like all pans, good heating properties and durability are the important features--and since this is a pan you'll use for many tasks, good heating properties--i.e., full cladding--are a must (not an option, as with Dutch ovens and stock pots). Our favorite is All-Clad's tri-ply clad stainless chef's pan.
These pans should always come with a lid. A stainless lid is best because it's more durable.
A helper handle is also a nice feature.
The only chef's pan we could find with all of these features is the All-Clad. You may be able to find less expensive ones if you're willing to live with a glass lid and/or nonstick coating, neither of which we recommend.
How Much Should You Spend on a Chef's Pan?
Since it's an optional pan, we wish we could find one we liked for a little less, but we couldn't. If you don't want to pay All-Clad prices for a chef's pan, consider getting the smaller sauciér pan (this Demeyere sauciér is a superb pan at a reasonable price) or--cheapest of all--a carbon steel wok.
BUY All-Clad saucier/chef's pan ON AMAZON NOW:
Should You Buy Sets or Individual Pans?
Sets are a great way to get a lot of pieces all at once for a good price. However, you have to be careful. If you won't use all the pieces in the set, is it really a good deal? You also have to pay careful attention to the size of the pieces, because all too often, the pieces are small. It's common for sets to have two small sauce pans--1-quart and 2-quart, for example--and two small skillets--8-inch and 10-inch. These pans are too small for most everyday uses, unless you cook only for one person.
On the other hand, it's nice to have matching pieces, and you can augment your set with larger (or smaller) pieces to match as you figure out what you need. So if you do buy a set, we suggest you buy a small set--5 to 7 pieces--and one that has pieces you know you'll use.
Another strategy, particularly if you stick to the essentials, is to invest in two or three top quality pieces and spend less on the pieces that don't need top-notch heating properties. For example, you could invest your money in a Demeyere Proline skillet, an All-Clad Deep Sauté pan, and a le Creuset Dutch oven, then choose Cuisinart MC Pro or Tramontina for the rest of your pieces.
There's no right or wrong answer here. It's in what you want and how much you want to spend.
Buying Cookware on Amazon: Smart or Not So Much?
If you're confident of what you're buying--that is, if you've done a little more research than just browsing through Amazon reviews--then Amazon is an excellent place to buy cookware. It's usually going to have the best prices (unless you hit a sale at a kitchen store like Sur la Table), and if you've got Amazon Prime, you're guaranteed free shipping.
Amazon also supplies their own warranty above and beyond the seller's and the manufacturer's, so you've got even more buyer protection than you'll get at other sites.
What we do caution against is choosing a cookware brand based solely on the number of positive reviews on Amazon. Why? First, most reviews are written in the first days of ownership, when buyers are still in the honeymoon phase with their new cookware. If something goes wrong, people don't always bother to update their positive review. Another reason is that you don't know buyers' backgrounds. If they've never used anything but low-end cookware, then they might give an overly glowing review to mediocre clad stainless; just because it's the best cookware they've ever used doesn't necessarily mean it's the best quality you can get. In fact, it doesn't even mean it's the best quality cookware at a certain price point.
There is a huge quality range in cookware, especially clad stainless. It is not all the same.
So if you do your research and know what you want, Amazon is an excellent place to buy cookware. However, you should also check other kitchen sites and stores for deals and sales. You might get lucky and find a closeout price at Williams-Sonoma or Sur la Table. In general, prices will be higher at these boutique stores--but check anyway, because you don't want to miss the stellar deals they can sometimes have.
How to do that research? We have a number of excellent articles in our Cookware Archives that can get you started. Or, if you trust us and believe we know what we're talking about, you can just take our word: the best clad stainless brands are Demeyere, All-Clad, Tramontina, and Cuisinart Multiclad Pro. These aren't the only good brands, but they offer either the very best quality at a premium price (Demeyere, All-Clad), or very good quality for a very affordable price (Cuisinart MC-Pro, Tramontina).
Most cooking sites have an article on essential pieces, and the list varies considerably. Our list is comprehensive enough to make every cooking task doable yet is still minimal, and our list of optional pieces allow you round out your collection based on your individual cooking style. We leave baking and other kitchen tools for another post.
What do you think of our list? Do you have a different idea of what the essential cookware pieces are? Let us know in the comments below.
And thanks for reading!